It is clear that the provision of Kadhi courts in Kenya's draft constitution has become a matter of national debate. This article aims at informing the on-going debate by setting out basic facts about Kadhi courts that appear to have been ignored in the debate and analysis.
Another must-read, this one detailing the history of Kadhi's courts in Kenya
Showing posts with label Constitution of Kenya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Constitution of Kenya. Show all posts
Friday, April 16, 2010
Open Thread: Discussing the 'Yes' and 'No' Campaigns on the Proposed Constitution
Everyone it seems agrees that the proposed constitution is far from perfect, even defective. The contention is whether or not those defects are of such a fundamental nature as to render the document unacceptable, even worse than the status quo.
What is your informed opinion of the draft? Is it better than the current document and in what ways? Also, what are the social, economic and political costs of replacing the old one? Are we discarding an unsavory part of our history and if so, are we doomed to repeat it? Discuss in comments below.
What is your informed opinion of the draft? Is it better than the current document and in what ways? Also, what are the social, economic and political costs of replacing the old one? Are we discarding an unsavory part of our history and if so, are we doomed to repeat it? Discuss in comments below.
Wednesday, March 03, 2010
Office of the Public Defender
Kituo Cha Sheria, the oldest legal aid and human rights organization established in 1973 is shocked to realize that the Public Defender's office has been removed from the Proposed Draft Constitution released by the Committee of Experts on 23rd February 2010. This removal comes after a recent article of the costing for provision of legal aid services having been done by the Ministry of Finance.
More.
More.
A new constitution this year
Even the most dyed-in-the-wool pessimist might now begin hoping that Kenya could have a new constitution before the year’s end. Op-ed pages in most Kenyan publications indicate a general enthusiasm for what has come our way from the latest Naivasha process, with some hailing it as modern and progressive.
More... .
More... .
Wednesday, February 17, 2010
Addressing the Senate and Devolution
If the Committee Of Experts has decided to eschew the Parliamentary Select Committee's (PSC) proposal on the makeup, role and functioning of the propose senate, as has been reported in the press, and has instead recommended an empowered senate with legislative powers and directly elected members, the question that presents itself is what will become of the PSC's proposal on devolution.
Read here, as Jones Mereu challenges the creation of a devolved county (unit) with only administrative powers.
Read here, as Jones Mereu challenges the creation of a devolved county (unit) with only administrative powers.
Monday, February 01, 2010
From Imperial President to King: a people betrayed
Members of Parliament have betrayed the people of Kenya, particularly the majority poor and exploited and the struggle for a new progressive national constitution.
No wonder the majority of the MPs that are tampering with the constitution in Naivasha have never been involved in the struggle for democracy in the country. They were part of the dictatorship that was opposed to democratic reforms.
While patriots and progressive Kenyans were being persecuted by the Moi and Kenyatta regimes for struggling for liberation from dictatorship, those who are now purporting to decide about the constitution for Kenya were accumulating wealth through corrupt deals. The few of the MPs at Naivasha that were reformers yesterday have now turned into opportunists and traitors and are either silent or collude with those who are manufacturing the constitution which Kenyans should reject.
Social Democratic Party chair Mwandawiro Mghanga weighs in on the Naivasha Consensus.
No wonder the majority of the MPs that are tampering with the constitution in Naivasha have never been involved in the struggle for democracy in the country. They were part of the dictatorship that was opposed to democratic reforms.
While patriots and progressive Kenyans were being persecuted by the Moi and Kenyatta regimes for struggling for liberation from dictatorship, those who are now purporting to decide about the constitution for Kenya were accumulating wealth through corrupt deals. The few of the MPs at Naivasha that were reformers yesterday have now turned into opportunists and traitors and are either silent or collude with those who are manufacturing the constitution which Kenyans should reject.
Social Democratic Party chair Mwandawiro Mghanga weighs in on the Naivasha Consensus.
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Citizenship Doesn't Stop at the Border
Daniel Waweru challenges Stephanie Migot's position on the creation of a new seat: Diaspora MP.
Read the rest of his argument here.
The issue here is representation -- not merely the right to agitate for reform. The argument, as given, is that by going abroad, and placing oneself at a remove from the democratic process one has given up the right to political representation. That's because it's not entirely clear how the other reasons are supposed to work. Paying taxes can't be a necessary condition of political representation, since tax-evaders; all those whose earnings fall below the minimum taxable amount; the churches and charities which take direct tax exemptions; members of religious orders who take vows of poverty and the MPs who so famously managed to protect their incomes from the taxman, all retain their right to participate and representation. Presence in the country for voting purposes simply folds into the first point about living abroad, since what matters here is the effect of location on one's right to political representation.
Read the rest of his argument here.
Against an MP with Air Miles
An article published in the Daily Nation brought one John Maina to national attention when he mooted the idea of Kenyans living abroad – the diaspora – having their own representative in government. According to the article, the Kenya Community Abroad (KCA), a US-based Kenyan advocacy group, is lobbying the Committee of Experts to create an “Abroad Constituency” who would then have an MP to represent the interests of Kenyans living abroad.
My instant reaction, as I posted to my Twitter account, was a resounding “Hell to the no!”
Stephanie Migot explains her position.
My instant reaction, as I posted to my Twitter account, was a resounding “Hell to the no!”
Stephanie Migot explains her position.
The Hoax that is the Naivasha Deal
The Parliamentary Select Committee is finally showing its true colors. It has shown that it can bastardize the people’s document to suit the narrow whims of just a handful of people in Parliament. The deal reached by 26 MPs in Naivasha is a hoax that Kenyans must reject even at the risk of not having a new constitution.
Jerry Okungu is not happy by the PSC's recommended draft constitution. Read on.
Jerry Okungu is not happy by the PSC's recommended draft constitution. Read on.
Friday, January 29, 2010
Part II: PSC Scores a Victory for a Rational and Progressive Kenyan Future
The reformation of our culture of politics, explained in Part 1 of this essay to be as important as the reform of our political institutions entails an analysis of how each of our other choices for institutional organization would work to curb the vices and weaknesses of our present political culture.
In this spirit, if we take a look at the particular form of hybrid government that has been proposed by the Committee of Experts, can it be in doubt that it does little to reform our political culture?
Continue reading.
In this spirit, if we take a look at the particular form of hybrid government that has been proposed by the Committee of Experts, can it be in doubt that it does little to reform our political culture?
Continue reading.
Part I: PSC Scores a Victory for a Rational and Progressive Kenyan Future
The decision of the Parliamentary Select Committee on the Constitution to adopt a purely presidential form of government for the revised draft constitution, while certainly coming as a surprise to most, must nonetheless be heralded as a very important step towards achieving transformational change in our political organization as a nation.
Continue... .
Continue... .
Wednesday, January 13, 2010
Post-Debate Draft Constitution
Published here is the Revised version of the Harmonised Draft Constitution. These revisions were collected during a one month period of debate and reflection. Various groups and individuals presented their opinions, offering suggestions, lamenting exclusions and praising or critiquing inclusions. Were your submitted views considered? What do you make of the end product?
Tuesday, February 26, 2008
Recipe for a Constitutional Compromise
Although the government has come in for the most severe vilification for its insistence that any resolution to the current crisis be concluded within the framework of the Constitution of Kenya, all indications are that the government is justified in its reluctance.
The government's position is informed by the current Constitution, the rule of law, and by the conventions and political culture in America.
Read more from Muciimi Mbatia here.
The government's position is informed by the current Constitution, the rule of law, and by the conventions and political culture in America.
Read more from Muciimi Mbatia here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)